A Long Island staple, inspired by the Mediterranean.
For over three decades, Jonathan’s has blended comforting American favorites with fresh Mediterranean flavors—crafted from scratch and served with timeless hospitality in the heart of Garden City Park.
Voted Best American Restaurant in 2024 by Long Island Press
★★★★★
Voted Best American Restaurant in 2024 by Long Island Press ★★★★★
Family owned and operated since 1992
Family-owned for three decades, Jonathan’s remains a trusted Long Island staple—serving dishes with heart, history, and a touch of Mediterranean flavor.
Fresh, local, and high-quality ingredients
We hold ourselves to the highest standards—using fresh, high-quality ingredients like Bell & Evans True Organic Chicken and seasonal produce in every dish.
A space for every occasion, big or small
From intimate gatherings to large celebrations, our flexible event spaces, personalized service, and custom menus make every occasion truly memorable.
Upcoming events and promotions
Restaurant Week
Enjoy a 3-course prix fixe menu for Long Island Restaurant Week Sunday 11/2 - Sunday 11/9
LI Restaurant week menu is $39. additional premium entrees can be upgraded for additional fee
3 Courses, 1 Price
Enjoy our 3-course prix fixe—available Monday–Friday for lunch ($29) and Monday–Thursday for dinner ($40).
Menus change regularly, call for details.
Excludes Holidays
Thanksgiving
Let Jonathan’s handle Thanksgiving this year! Offering a 3 course Traditional Turkey or Ham Dinner along with a condensed holiday menu available
Holiday reservations must be made by phone. Online reservation systems will be turned off on holidays
Half-Priced Wines
Join us every Tuesday night for dinner and enjoy 50% off select bottles of wine—perfect for pairing and sharing.
What our customers say
Looking for a space to host a special occasion?
From intimate gatherings to large celebrations, our flexible event spaces, personalized service, and custom menus make every occasion truly memorable.
-
Celebrate new beginnings with a welcoming event space, custom menus, and attentive service—ideal for intimate gatherings that honor the parents-to-be in style.
-
Toast to love with a tailored event that feels personal and polished. From light bites to full lunches, our team helps create a memorable setting for the bride and her guests.
-
Get together before the big day in a relaxed, private setting. Enjoy curated menus and exceptional service designed to make your celebration feel effortless and elegant.
-
Make the season bright with a festive event in one of our private or semi-private rooms. Whether it’s a casual lunch or full dinner party, we bring the cheer—and the catering.
-
Our catering spaces and flexible menus make it easy to host a birthday gathering that’s as special and unique as the guest of honor.
-
Impress clients or treat your team to a catered lunch or dinner in a refined, comfortable setting. We offer flexible layouts, AV support, and menus tailored to your needs.
Monthly Newsletter
Join the family!
Sign up for our newsletter and be the first to know about upcoming events, new specials, promotions and much more!
